Winnetkans Against
Value Erosion

Who We Are

We are business owners, doctors, lawyers, teachers and neighbors. We are community members, just like you, who want to support good governance, fair property rights, strong property values, exceptional education and equality among all Winnetka residents.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did this group come together?

What is the biggest issue driving this group?

What steps is the group taking to combat new, harmful policies?

How can I get involved?

Issues We Are
Defending

Property Owners Rights

In February 2024, the Winnetka Village Board passed an overreaching ordinance that severely limits what homeowners can do to improve their homes and invites negative spillover effects onto the property values of owners across the village. We assert that this ordinance not only violates Illinois state law, but also ignores the concerns and priorities of Winnetka citizens. The Village Board conducted a predetermined process and did not listen to overwhelming voices that spoke out against these ordinances, and others.

Subscribe for Updates

* indicates required

Intuit Mailchimp

×

Our Efforts

Earlier this year, the Village Board approved an ordinance that dramatically restricts property rights and is expected to damage property values and increase property taxes across Winnetka over time.

The ordinance is expected to take 40% of buildable areas away from homeowners and lower their allowable home size by roughly 5-8%. This negative impact will most likely have “spillover” effects on properties values across Winnetka by reducing the pool of homeowners willing to adhere to such limitations and negatively impacting the perception of our community. While the impact on home values is nuanced, it is closely tied to how potential buyers perceive these restrictions, potential future restrictions and the competency of the Village Board.

No one would want to have their property rights drastically limited without fair process and compensation. And no one would want to put up with a process that unfairly disregards the opinions of residents. These restrictions will continue to negatively affect property values and taxes for everyone and drive potential neighbors away from our beautiful community.

Ordinance

Among the concerns we have, the ordinance states that the purpose of the ordinance was to improve safety and environmental impacts. However, there are no safety or environmental hazards. The Village Trustees, who are not experienced in such matters, never considered the amount of damage this ordinance would cause.

Lawsuit

There are two main legal issues that the board’s decision has presented. First, the board did not follow Illinois state law, specifically the La Salle/Sinclair Factors. Secondly, it has no plans to compensate landowners for diminished home values resulting from the ordinance.

The Winnetka Village Board is charged with fairly representing the opinions and concerns of the citizens it represents. However, the community’s vocal opposition has not been adequately reflected nor acknowledged. Experts did not conclude that Winnetka needed the ordinance. It was even stated early on, by trustees, that only small changes to the current, adequate permitting requirements were needed.

There are expectations set by history and Illinois state laws, including the rights of property owners. The board did not complete any work on how this ordinance might impact home values in Winnetka, and it ignored professional opinions about the potential negative impacts of the ordinance.

The new ordinances stated purpose is to improve the protection, environment or safety of the lakefront, as claimed but it fails to do so. If the ordinance’s purpose was adhered to, we would have supported it.Earlier this year, the Village Board approved an ordinance that dramatically restricts property rights and is expected to damage property values and increase property taxes across Winnetka over time.The ordinance is expected to take 40% of buildable areas away from homeowners and lower their allowable home size by roughly 5-8%. This negative impact will most likely have “spillover” effects on properties values across Winnetka by reducing the pool of homeowners willing to adhere to such limitations and negatively impacting the perception of our community. While the impact on home values is nuanced, it is closely tied to how potential buyers perceive these restrictions, potential future restrictions and the competency of the Village Board.No one would want to have their property rights drastically limited without fair process and compensation. And no one would want to put up with a process that unfairly disregards the opinions of residents. These restrictions will continue to negatively affect property values and taxes for everyone and drive potential neighbors away from our beautiful community.